Pagecraft NotesSoftware, shared drafts, and writing tips

Ask Beta Readers for Feedback That Helps the Next Draft

A beta reader can finish a manuscript and still be unsure what feedback would help. Explain the stage of the draft and ask a few questions about the reading experience. That gives the reader a smaller job than commenting on everything in the book.

In this article

Say what kind of feedback is needed

If chapters may still move or disappear, say so. Ask for reactions to the story before detailed punctuation notes. A reader should know whether the draft needs structural feedback or a final proofread.

Agree on a deadline and say whether notes from an unfinished read are welcome. If someone stops reading, ask where they stopped and why. A confusing chapter and a busy week mean different things for the revision.

Ask about passages the reader remembers

Questions about a particular moment are easier to act on than a score for the whole book. These can be included in a short reader brief:

  • Where did the story become hard to follow?
  • Which character decision felt unconvincing?
  • Where did attention drift?
  • Which part made you want to keep reading?
  • What did the ending leave unresolved?

Separate the reaction from the proposed fix

A reader might suggest deleting a character because that character’s purpose is unclear. Keep the observation about the purpose before deciding whether deletion is the answer.

Compare comments about the same passage. If several readers lose track of the plan in chapter eight, work out what information is missing there. A targeted change may address several comments at once.

Related reading: When Google Docs Stops Being Enough for a Novel

Filed under Reader feedback